Why Your Scenes Feel Flat

A flat scene is one that delivers its information and nothing else. The characters say what they need to say, the plot point lands, and the scene ends having done its job — but it left no impression. Flat scenes are technically functional and dramatically dead.

The cause is almost always that the scene is doing only one thing. Great scenes work on multiple levels at once.

Every scene needs a surface and a subsurface

On the surface, a scene is about its literal content — two people negotiating, a character making a phone call. Underneath, a good scene is about something else: a shift in power, a relationship changing, a fear surfacing. When a scene only has the surface, it feels flat.

Before writing a scene, decide what is happening beneath the obvious action. The literal conversation can be about dinner plans while the real scene is about whether these two people still trust each other.

Give characters conflicting agendas

Flat scenes often have everyone wanting the same thing. When characters are aligned, there is nothing to play. Give the people in the scene different, even opposing, goals — and let those goals collide. Conflict does not require hostility; it requires that not everyone can get what they want.

Even small frictions add dimension. One character wants to leave, the other wants to keep talking. One wants the truth, the other wants to avoid it.

Enter late, leave early, and change something

A scene that begins after the small talk and ends before the resolution forces energy into the frame. And a scene should never leave its characters where it found them — by the end, something should have shifted, however slightly. Information learned, a decision made, a relationship altered.

If you read a scene back and the characters are in the same emotional position they started in, that is your flatness. Find the change, or find the cut.

← All articles